The waterfront: what we heard last night, and what happens on Thursday

14 October 2026 · Helensburgh Community Council

Thank you to everyone who came to The Tower last night. Here’s a short round-up of the evening, the slides Dr Peter Brown and Fiona Baker presented, and what you can do before councillors decide on Thursday.

Councillors decide this Thursday, 15 October Argyll and Bute Council’s Policy & Resources Committee will consider the officers’ recommendation to sell the waterfront Common Good land for a supermarket. Email your councillors today and ask them to speak for you. Their addresses are below.

What we covered

The history of the waterfront

We started in 1838, when the waterfront was granted to the burgh’s councillors “without the power of Alienation”: held for the people of Helensburgh, not for the Council to sell as it chooses. Since then, the site has been repeatedly protected from supermarket development. A Co-operative supermarket was refused in 1993, a Safeway was refused in 2000, and a supermarket was dropped from the 2012 masterplan after the community rejected the 2011 draft.

What the consultation told the Council

Next, the Council’s own consultation. 3,430 people responded, and 94.8% of them opposed the sale. That’s more than 9 out of 10, or about 3,250 people. Most raised more than one reason: 9 in 10 said no supermarket, 7 in 10 said don’t sell Common Good land, and 3 in 4 said keep it for the community.

How Common Good land works

Then the rules. Common Good land can’t simply be sold like any other council asset. Officers now say this site has become Common Good “of the alienable type”, which would mean no Court consent is needed to sell it. The report offers no title analysis or legal opinion to support that, and the Council has refused to release its legal advice. The site still isn’t on a Common Good register, and the Council says it has “no current proposals to establish a common good fund”.

The problems with the officers’ report

Finally, the report going to councillors on Thursday. We set out ten issues with it. Among them: it calls 94.8% opposition “largely oppose”, and still recommends the sale. It sticks with a decision made in 2023 after a one-week exercise involving just 83 people. It relies on a 2024 retail study built on survey data from 2007. And it would put the money from the sale towards the leisure centre, which is already built, rather than into a Common Good fund.

The slides

Download the full presentation, or just the part you’re interested in:

What you can do now

1. Email your councillors today

Thursday’s Policy & Resources Committee is the next stage of the decision. Not every councillor sits on that committee, but any councillor can attend and tell it what their constituents think. Ask yours to do that, and to let you know afterwards that they did. You can copy the note below and add your own words.

Dear Councillor [name],

I’m writing to ask you to represent the people of Helensburgh at the Policy & Resources Committee this Thursday, 15 October. If you don’t sit on the committee, please attend and make the point for us.

In the Council’s own consultation, 94.8% of the 3,430 people who responded opposed selling the waterfront Common Good land. Please make sure the committee hears the strength of that feeling. The people of Helensburgh want this land kept for the common good of the town, not sold for commercial retail. I’m asking you to vote, or speak, against the recommendation to sell.

We are relying on you to carry our voice into that room. I’d be grateful if you could let me know afterwards that you did.

Yours sincerely, [Your name and address]

Helensburgh Central

Helensburgh and Lomond South

Lomond North

2. Come to Thursday’s meeting

The Policy & Resources Committee meets on Thursday 15 October. You can see the agenda and papers, including the officers’ report, on the Council’s website.

3. Make a formal complaint

If you took part in the consultation and feel your views are being ignored, tell the Council directly: lodge a formal complaint. Choose the category “Development and Infrastructure Services”.

4. Pass this on

Send this page to anyone who responded to the consultation but couldn’t make it last night.

We’ll post an update after Thursday’s committee.

Helensburgh Community Council

95% said no. Council officers want to sell the waterfront anyway.

9 October 2026 · Helensburgh Community Council

3,430 of you responded to the Council’s consultation on the Helensburgh waterfront. 95% said no to selling the Common Good land for a supermarket. Council officers are now recommending the sale goes ahead regardless. Here’s what’s happening, why we think it’s wrong, and what you can do before councillors decide next week.

Public meeting: Tuesday 13 October, 7pm, The Tower, Helensburgh
Free, and everyone is welcome. Come and hear what’s in the report before councillors vote on Thursday 15 October.

Can’t make it? Lodge a formal complaint with Argyll and Bute Council and tell your councillors what you think.

What the consultation said

Argyll and Bute Council asked the community whether it should sell the waterfront Common Good land to supermarket developer Forrest Developments Ltd. The response was huge, and it was clear.

3,430 people took part. 95% of them rejected the sale.

“That is one of the strongest, most unified expressions of public opinion ever recorded in Argyll and Bute,” said Dr Peter Brown, Convener of Helensburgh Community Council. “The community’s views could not be clearer, yet the report attempts to minimise and sideline them.”

What officers are recommending

Despite that result, a report going to the Council’s Policy & Resources Committee on Thursday 15 October recommends that councillors:

  • sell the Common Good land
  • finalise the deal with Forrest Developments Ltd
  • put the money from the sale towards the cost of the waterfront leisure centre, which is currently closed.

The report, from Douglas Hendry, Executive Director for Commercial Services, says the supermarket proposal “represents the option which reflects the best interests of the inhabitants of the former Burgh of Helensburgh”.

“It is difficult to imagine a more direct contradiction of the consultation evidence,” said Dr Brown.

Why we think this is wrong

The community has already answered the question. A statutory consultation that 95% of respondents reject shouldn’t be set aside because officers prefer a different outcome.

The land’s Common Good status is being reframed. The report says the site has “lost the character and nature of Common Good of the inalienable type”, which would mean the Council doesn’t need a Court’s consent to sell it. That is the officers’ opinion. The Council has refused to release its legal advice under Freedom of Information rules, which raises serious questions about transparency and about how Common Good assets are being protected.

The money wouldn’t stay with the Common Good. Common Good land is held in trust for the people of Helensburgh. Using the proceeds to help pay for the leisure centre, on the grounds that it was built for the burgh some years ago, doesn’t show proper regard for the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015 or the Council’s legal duties in managing Common Good assets.

The case for a supermarket rests on weak evidence. “Officers continue to push a supermarket as the only viable option,” said Polly Jones, Vice Convener. “They’re relying on an out-of-date retail study, an earlier engagement exercise involving just 83 people, and a bias towards a commercial developer. Viability can’t be defined only by what a private developer can deliver or by a short-term capital receipt. Not when it’s Common Good land held in trust for the people of Helensburgh.”

What we’re asking councillors to do

We’re calling on elected councillors to reject the recommendation, uphold their fiduciary duty, and respect the community’s voice.

“The people of Helensburgh have spoken: clearly, decisively, and in good faith,” said Ms Jones. “It is now time for councillors to do the right thing and stop this sale.”

What you can do

Come to the public meeting

Tuesday 13 October, 7pm, The Tower, Helensburgh. Free, and everyone is welcome.

We’ll brief you on the report and on Thursday’s Policy & Resources Committee meeting, and ask you once more to show your support for keeping this land in public ownership. We’ve invited Council officers, councillors, Forrest Developments Ltd and the Co-operative to attend.

Make a formal complaint

If you took part in the consultation and feel your views are being ignored, you can tell the Council directly. Residents and businesses can lodge a formal complaint here:

argyllandbute.custhelp.com/app/LAP_Forms/LAP_Complaints

Tell your councillors

Councillors make the decision on Thursday 15th October, not officers. Let them know what you think before they vote.

– Local councillors

If you live in Helensburgh Central, you have four councillors:

If you live in Helensburgh and Lomond South, you have three councillors:

If you live in Lomond North, you have three councillors:

Helensburgh Community Council

Public meeting regarding Helensburgh Waterfront Common Good land.

This will be held on Tuesday 13th October at 7pm in the main auditorium of The Tower, Sinclair Street, Helensburgh.

The purpose of this meeting is to inform the community about the next stage of the Waterfront Development plans. We know that there were over 3,400 responses to the public consultation that was held during the summer. This level of community engagement was incredible, and we believe a majority will strongly oppose disposing of this Common Good land.

The meeting will provide the community with informed guidance on the upcoming council meeting on 15 October.